A recent paper from the lab, led by PhD student Melanie Denommé, examines a foundational assumption in reptile husbandry: that animals will inherently prefer naturalistic enclosures over simpler, more utilitarian ones. Using bearded dragons (Pogona vitticeps) as a model species, Melanie conducted preference tests in which lizards were given free choice between naturalistic and standard enclosure styles (Figure 1). Critically however, individuals had been reared under two different housing conditions and tested at multiple time points across their lives, allowing us to shed light on preferences shaped by experience. Contrary to expectations, the dragons did not show an immediate or universal preference for the more naturalistic enclosures. Instead, their choices were strongly influenced by prior housing conditions, age, and timing of the tests, demonstrating that familiarity and developmental context play an important role in how captive reptiles evaluate their environments.

Despite the absence of a consistent enclosure-level preference, the behavioural data told a more nuanced and compelling story. When lizards engaged in key species-typical behaviours such as climbing, digging, and hiding, they overwhelmingly used naturalistic resources rather than the simpler substitutes provided in standard enclosures. This finding suggests that while reptiles may not always “choose” a naturalistic enclosure outright, these environments are clearly superior for facilitating motivated behaviours that are closely linked to welfare. As part of Melanie’s broader PhD research program, this work emphasizes the importance of empirically testing husbandry assumptions rather than relying only on tradition or aesthetics alone, and it provides concrete guidance on which enclosure features matter most from the animal’s perspective. More than that, we argue that context and experience are important considerations in these kinds of studies.
Citation
Denommé, M and Tattersall, GJ. 2026. Try before you buy: Preferences for naturalistic-style enclosures are influenced by experience in bearded dragons (Pogona vitticeps). Journal of Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 295:106887. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.applanim.2025.106887