Handle with care: when measuring temperature changes the temperature

Measuring body temperature should seem straightforward, but in ectotherms, the act of measuring can be part of the problem. For especially small amphibians in particular, common approaches like cloacal thermometry require restraint and direct contact, raising the possibility that handling itself alters body temperature before it is even recorded. In this study, we asked a simple but important question: does brief, gentle handling measurably change the body temperature of salamanders?

Using infrared thermography, we examined how short periods of handling affected skin temperature in two closely related mole salamanders, the blue-spotted salamander (Ambystoma laterale) and the spotted salamander (A. maculatum). We also combined field measurements with controlled laboratory experiments to tease apart the effects of physical contact, heat transfer, and behaviour.


The answer was clear. Even short handling periods caused salamanders to warm rapidly. In the field, handled animals were consistently warmer than unhandled controls, with the head warming more than the rest of the body. Not surprisingly, smaller salamanders showed larger temperature changes, suggesting body size plays an important role in how quickly heat is gained.

Change in skin temperature of yellow spotted salamanders either handled or placed on a warm plate (set to the same temperature as human handler).



In the lab, salamanders placed on a warm surface (set to hand temperature) also warmed up, but not as much as animals that were actually handled. This tells us that handling is not simply about contact with something warm. While we don’t know precisely why yet, the most likely explanation is that salamanders manifest a stronger cardiovascular response to human handling and the heat that they pick up is transferred more quickly throughout the body.

Temperature changes matter from a behavioural perspective. Warmer salamanders were more likely to become active, regardless of whether that warmth came from handling or from contact with a warm surface. That means handling can influence not only the temperature we measure, but also the behaviour we observe.
Taken together, these results highlight a subtle but important issue: brief handling can rapidly alter body temperature, sometimes at rates comparable to experimental heat stress studies. For researchers, this has implications for data accuracy in thermal biology. More broadly, it is a reminder that even well-intentioned, gentle handling can have unintended physiological effects, especially for small ectotherms.

Some caveats: this study is not to be interpreted as alarmist. Warming up from being in contact with warm temperatures is a pretty obvious expectation. These results would only have possible impacts for studies concerned with accurate temperature measurements or those that perform very brief behavioural observations during or immediately after handling (which is probably very rare) that are temperature dependent. And as one of the reviewers of the manuscript rightly pointed out, we measured surface temperatures, which will differ and lag with core temperature measurements.

We do note that there is a related study appearing in the same issue of the Journal of Thermal Biology highlighting similar cautions as this one, and that particular study actually measures core temperature of really tiny frogs!

Citation

Giacometti, D, Montes, LF, Denommé, M, Andrade, DV, and Tattersall, GJ. Handle with care: the thermal consequences of short-term handling in mole salamanders. Journal of Thermal Biology, 136: 104390. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtherbio.2026.104390

Toucans of the atlantic

Earlier this summer, I was lucky enough to visit the Isle of May, Scotland to fulfill a long-time ambition to collect thermal image data on puffins in the wild. Ever since we published our work on the toucan in 2009, I have wanted to study the puffins, examining evidence for elevated capacity to control or distribute body heat through their uniquely colourful bill. Living in a cool climate with a large radiator like their bill presents a unique opportunity to test our hypotheses. In spring of 2018 I managed to visit the Elliston, Newfoundland puffin colony to start this project, but the distance to view a little too far to obtain high quality results.

Well, the short story is that they do show an extraordinary capacity to do so! Here is just a sample image (from the 200 Gb of videos):

Active and basking Atlantic puffins show capacity for intense heat transfer to the bill. The one above has recently landed back at the colony, presumably foraging although in this case, there is no evidence of food. Other images show cool bills, as we have seen in many other bird species, demonstrating the vasomotor control over blood flow to the bill is a fairly generalised phenomenon.
Infrared thermal video of an Atlantic puffin in May 2018 – early arrival at nest and investigating burrows.
Atlantic puffin in the rain.

If I only had the time to conduct the data analysis, I could put some numbers on these values. I certainly have my work cut out for me, examining those returning from the water with food vs. those basking and resting. I have a few other thoughts about these data that I hope to extract.

Many thanks must go to the town of Elliston, Newfoundland and the Atlantic puffin colony there, the Centre for Ecology and Hydrology (UK), the Isle of May (Scotland) Scientists, and especially Mark Newell for hosting me at the Isle of May, and Mike Harris for introducing us. Sorry it took so long to post this.

Further Reading

Tattersall, GJ, Arnaout, B, and Symonds, MRE.  2017.  The evolution of the avian bill as a thermoregulatory organ. Biological Reviews 92: 1630-1656. doi:10.1111/brv.12299

Greenberg, R, Cadena, V, Danner, RM, and Tattersall GJ. 2012. Heat loss may explain bill size differences between birds occupying different habitats. PLoS One, 7: e40933. 

Symonds, MRE and Tattersall, GJ. 2010. Geographical variation in bill size across bird species provides evidence for Allen’s rule.American Naturalist. 176: 188-197.

Tattersall, GJ, Andrade, DV, and Abe, AS. 2009. Heat exchange from the toucan bill reveals a controllable vascular thermal radiator.Science, 325: 468-470.